Developing people for a job with no answer key.

In my last newsletter, I wrote that in a world where technology commoditizes the work, relationships and capabilities are where professional services companies will win. Technical excellence isn't going anywhere, since it's the price of entry and what gets you considered. It's just no longer what gets you chosen.

If that's true, it raises the next question: how do we need to develop people differently?

Back in the day, there were two silver bullets for success in professional services: book of business and technical expertise. Bring in the clients, crank out the work, rinse and repeat. We built our whole talent model around that formula, training young professionals as technicians meant to crank out work and support the billable hour, then promoting the ones who are best at it.

But the skills that make someone a great technician aren't the skills it takes to lead people or steward a client relationship. Those skills don't show up on their own, so they have to be built on purpose, through intentional development.

Jobs with no answer keys.

Our profession has traditionally trained people on problems that have answers. We select the people who are best at that, and we're right to, because it's demanding work and it takes time to get good at it. Then we promote them into jobs that have no answer key.

I was talking recently with a leader who runs an organization full of subject matter experts and does that high-end technical work himself. He told me leading people is as hard as the technical work, if not harder, because there's no constant fact base. You've got many different personalities and many different inputs at the same time, and to him it felt like "holding jello." I liked that analogy.

To me, leading people is like putting a very abstract puzzle together and trying to get the right piece next to the right piece, and nothing tells you when you've got it right.

I remember my first day sitting at my desk as a Managing Partner thinking, "What the hell do I do now?"

It took being asked to build an international services group from scratch to pull me out of technician work, and even then there was no lightning-strike moment when I shed my technician armor, just a slow, gradual shift.

Technical excellence still matters, because the work has to get done. But the landscape is changing, and the way we select and develop people needs to change too.

The same is true on the client side. As one of our partners put it, the production's not the problem. It's the stewardship of the relationship. And nobody comes out of school ready-made to be relational in a client service seat, so that skill has to be developed too.

So what do we do next?

For most of my career, we developed people by teaching them the work and having them repeat it until they got good at it. The production was the main objective, and the learning was a byproduct.

That isn't going to cut it anymore (frankly, it never did). A young person shouldn't sit and do 500 tax returns to learn the trade, because that repetitive work is going to automation.

The good news is that the same technology creates the capacity to develop people differently. When someone gets a project done in half the time, they can use the time they get back to go on a sales call, take on a learning exercise, or pursue a development opportunity.

That development doesn't happen in a classroom. When one of our senior partners asked me what his role is in the company we're building, I told him to keep doing what he's doing and bring a young professional to every meeting. Take them into the client meetings, the prospect meetings, and the challenging client calls. Give them experiences, let them screw up so you can teach them, and don't do the work for them.

As for which skills to build, these are the ones I'd focus on:

  • Curiosity. Come alongside more senior people, ask questions, and get curious about clients and what they'll need next.

  • Pattern recognition. Listen hard to what you're experiencing, then apply it to a completely different situation. Time in the chair gives you experience, but it doesn't automatically give you judgment.

  • Relationship stewardship. Asking, listening, and solving problems for people, which is what clients will choose you for.

  • Connecting the dots, shifting mindsets, and communicating with intention, the skills every leader eventually needs.

Leaving all of this to osmosis is just using hope as a strategy. Can it happen? Sure. But at what cost? Time, mostly, and the compounding you give up when someone learns these skills at the end of the journey instead of the start.

A different muscle.

Technology is going to keep taking on more of the technical work, which makes promoting the best technician and hoping it works out a riskier decision each day.

The companies that win will start building the critical thinking and relational skills from the beginning, through real experience, instead of waiting until someone is handed a role that demands them.

The next chapter of professional services is going to be less about the work and more about building capabilities and developing client relationships. The way we prepare future leaders needs to adapt to match it.

With intention,

Alan Whitman
CEO at Nichols Cauley

ps… how do you see the future of our profession, and what skills do you think matter most for people to develop? Would enjoy hearing from you.


Whenever you're ready, here are 3 ways to engage with me, my content, and what we're building at Nichols Cauley:

  1. ​Follow me on Linkedin for daily posts on leadership, thinking differently, and building a company in public.

  2. ​Buy my book, Break the Mold,​ to read in depth about how to apply my principles to achieve transformational change, growth, and scale simultaneously.

  3. Join us on the journey: View career opportunities at Nichols Cauley and join on us as we build something really special.

Become a leader who BREAKS THE MOLD™. Receive future emails in your inbox.

Next
Next

When the Work Stops Being the Differentiator.